chenmu:recently,manyministershavevisitedtheprince,howshouldihandlethis?sirtaughtme。
xiaofan:ithink,theysimplywenttovisittheprince,it‘snotaboutformingapoliticalparty,butetiquetteishierarchical,onlybyobeyingitwilltherebenoconfusionbetweenthekingandtheministers,althoughthecrownprincewasnoble,hewasalsoacourtieroftheking,onthewintersolstice,theministersvisitedthecrownprinceandpresentedgifts,itdoesnotconformtoetiquetteandrules,youshouldorderthattheybeforbiddentodoso,atthesametime,ihopeyouwillnotlistentorumorstoprotectyourfeelings,onlythenwillthecountrybestable。
chenmu:sirisright,irespectfullyacceptyou。
陈牧:今少傅卢坦,教导世子不力,寡人欲黜之,可乎?先生教我。
萧凡:臣以为,卢坦以天挺良才,元勋佐命,为众所疾,以至废弃;愿大王录其大功,忘其小过,弘君王之慈,顾天性之义,迁之小县,观其所为:若能迁善,渐更增益;如或不悛,贬削非晚。
陈牧:先生之言是也,寡人谨受教。
chenmu:nowlutandidnotseriouslyteachthecrownprince,therefore,iwanttoremovehim,sirwhatdoyouthink?
xiaofan:ithink,lutanhadgoodtalentsandgreatmerits,otherswerejealousofhimsotheyslanderedhim,evenyou‘regoingtoremovehim,iwantyoutorememberhisgreatexploitsandignorehislittlemistakes,youaretoshowthebenevolenceofthekingandtotakecareofthewillofthepeople,demotehimtocountymagistrateandobservehisactions,ifhedoesagoodjob,yougivehimapromotion,otherwise,it‘snottoolateforyoutodismisshim。
chenmu:sirisright,irespectfullyacceptyou。
陈牧:汉唐士多而府史少,今掾史百倍于前,减则不济,何也?先生教我。
萧凡:臣以为,古人委任责成,岁终考其殿最,案不重校,文不繁悉,府史之任,掌要目而已。今之文簿,恒虑覆治,若锻炼不密,则追证百年旧案。故谚云:‘老吏抱案死。’事繁政弊,职此之由也。往者州唯置纲纪,郡置守、丞,县置令而已。其馀具僚则长官自辟,受诏赴任,每州不过数十。今则不然,大小之官,悉由吏部,纤介之迹,皆属考功。省官不如省事,官事不省而望从容,其可得乎!
陈牧:先生之言是也,寡人谨受教。
chenmu:thereweremoreministersthancivilservantsinthehanandtangdynasties,nowithasahundredtimesmorecivilservantsthanbefore,iflayoffsaremade,thentheworkwillnotgowell,i‘mveryworriedaboutthat,sirtaughtmewhattodo?
xiaofan:ithink,theancientsassignedtaskstocivilservantsandusedresultsasacriterionforevaluation,butonlythelastoneisprocessed,casesarenotcorrectedmultipletimesandtherulesarenotcomplicated,thetaskofacivilservantistocommandtheoutline,now,civilservantsareafraidofbeingscrutinized,sotheyhandlecasesverystrictly,thereasonwhygovernmentaffairsarecomplicatedandbusyisprobablybecauseofthis,previously,therewereonlygovernors,mayors,andcountychiefs,andtheyrecruitasmallnumberofsubordinateofficers,butnowallofficialappointmentsaredecidedbythestatedepartment,andallmattersaretobeevaluated,itisbettertoreduceofficialsthantoreducegovernmentaffairs,itisimpossibletosaveyourmindwithoutsimplifyinggovernmentaffairs。
chenmu:sirisright,irespectfullyacceptyou。
陈牧:寡人闻,天子之职莫大于礼,何也?先生教我。
萧凡:臣以为,天子之职莫大于礼,礼莫大于分,分莫大于名,何谓礼?纲纪是也,何谓分?君臣是也,何谓名?公、侯、卿大夫是也,是故天子统三公,三公率诸侯,诸侯制卿大夫,然后能上下相保,而国家治安者也。
陈牧:先生之言是也,寡人谨受教。
chenmu:iheard,theemperor‘sgreatestdutywastopromoteetiquetteintheworld,sirwhatdoyouthink?
xiaofan:ithink,thefirsttaskofthekingwastoenforcetheliturgy,themostimportantthingintheliturgyistodividestatusandhierarchy,withit,orderbetweenkingsandministerscanbeestablished,thus,thekingwasabletocommandtheprincipalityandhisministers,becauseofthis,thegovernmentcanbeorderlyandthecountrycanbestable。
chenmu:sirisright,irespectfullyacceptyou。